Is getting a second dog a good idea?

Savannah Hamann • February 27, 2024

It can be so difficult to say no to an adorable puppy!

A little puppy sitting cute.

I remember when I first brought home Remi. 12 weeks old, and a bundle of non stop energy! We brought her everywhere we could, and she was spoiled rotten (still is 😉). As Remi grew up, we noticed that her mood and bubbly attitude started to decrease. This was outside the normal puppy hood into young adult hood settling. We confirmed everything health wise was good, so we turned to another possibility. Was Remi lonely?


Keep in mind Remi was seldom by herself. But we noticed that even when we would play with her, she didn’t seem incredibly interested. That is until we met up with our friends who also had a dog! When she was around other dogs, her whole attitude lit up! Her favorite thing to do is getting dogs to chase her (she’s really really fast #bordercolliemix) so having other dogs to play with was great for her.


That got us thinking, maybe Remi needed a companion that wasn’t one of us humans. There was a lot of thinking that went into our decision to ultimately get another dog. A LOT. I’ll list some of those out for you below.


What to consider when adding a second dog:


1: Can you financially afford it?

It’s no secret that owning a dog isn’t the cheapest thing in the world (especially if you’re lucky enough to get a dog with allergies… 🙋‍♀️) so it’s really important to evaluate your current (and anticipated) financial situation. A dog is a lifelong commitment!


2: Will it positively impact your household?

Key word there: household! Whether you are adopting an adult dog or you are bringing home a young puppy, there will be a transition for everyone (human and animal) within your household. So you need to make sure anyone who will be involved is in agreement and on the same page.


3: How do your current animals behave with other dogs?

How does your current dog behave around other dogs? If you have a cat, how does your cat (if you have one) behave with your current dog? How do YOU handle the dynamic of your animal(s) each day? Can YOU handle another being that will rely on you everyday? That’s a lot to consider! Adding another dog, adds more duties to your day (pun intended!)


4: Will you be able to stay with your new dog for a few days after bringing it home?

It’s very important that you are able to remain with your new dog/puppy for a few days after bringing it home. This will help dramatically with their transition, and it will help your current animals adjust to the newcomer. Do not leave your new dog/puppy alone with your current animals right away! It is important that you are there to watch and keep control of the situation. We don’t want any escalations while they all get used to each other!


5: Will your landlord or HOA allow multiple animals?

Now, I bring this up because if you get an animal and you are renting, most landlords will have rules on how many animals you can have. And they’ll often times have a pet fee. If you own your house and are in an HOA, some have rules against how many animals you can have on your property.

If you go against what the landlord allows, breach contract, they could evict you. Or make you get rid of the dog. And no one wants that! The HOA could fine you or potentially put a lean on your house. (That sounds crazy, but, it happens!) So make sure you check all of the necessary protocols or rules you may need to follow before adding your new pup.

A cute puppy sitting on the ground.

New Paragraph

By Savannah Hamann February 21, 2025
During my time as a professional dog trainer, one of the most common challenges I have helped people with is separation anxiety in dogs. It’s one of the most mentally and emotionally draining hurdles that someone can work through. If you’re like me, and most people I work with, seeing our dogs stressed out or upset or scared is incredibly difficult. My dogs are my family, and I love them more than most things in my life! To see them in such emotional distress is not on my top ten list. There is no way around it, separation anxiety is brutal. And, in most cases working through it is just as tough because it takes TIME - more time than people think. It also takes an insane amount of patience and consistency, not to mention building up our emotional wall so we can push through and get our dog into a better state of mind. What is separation anxiety in dogs? So what is separation anxiety and why is it such a monster to deal with? Think of it this way, your dog has developed such an attachment to you or such a fear of being alone or confined that they become irrational and their fight or flight instincts kick in where the only answer is to escape or otherwise face their impending doom… Doesn’t sound too fun right? When our dogs enter such a state they are basically on another planet mentally. Of course, there are different levels of separation anxiety, it isn’t always immediately a huge freak-out, but if left untreated it can and most likely will escalate to that. Some of the most common signs of separation anxiety are as follows: Excessive panting Continual lip licking Sweaty paws Pacing “Whale-eye” Timid body language Excessive barking/whining Destruction These are just a few signs of separation anxiety, but they also could be reactions from something else so we need to assess the entire situation before deciding what is causing the behavior. When a dog is in an intense reaction you’ll oftentimes see a combination of multiple signs. This could be excessive panting with their tongues all the way extended, dripping saliva onto their paws, the ground around them saturating their fur and the space they are in. They go through barking fits accompanied with pacing back and forth in the kennel or room you keep them in and from there, with no relief in sight, they resort to an escape attempt. This is where separation anxiety becomes very dangerous. Dogs can and will do whatever they can to get out of the situation. How do we help Separation Anxiety in dogs? If you’re like most people the thought or sight of your dog losing their mind because they are so scared or stressed is something you’d like to avoid at all costs. As with most behavioral challenges with dogs, there are things we can do to help prevent the issue or reshape and eliminate the reaction. One of the biggest things you can do if you have a new puppy is to leave them alone. That’s right! I said it… Leave your adorable little puppy alone in a safe space for a very short amount of time. I’m talking like stepping into another room and then returning a few moments later, amount of time. The idea here is that we want our puppy to start to learn that just because we leave them alone, it’s not the end of the world. The key here though is to always wait until your puppy is quiet before you go back in! The last thing you want to do is teach them that being boisterous and barky will get you to return. This is a similar concept as well for older dogs, or older dogs you may have rescued. If they are uncomfortable being alone we have to slowly expose them to that over a period of time. The idea is the same though, they need to learn that being alone is not a life or death scenario and they can and should be calm and relaxed. There is an exercise I like to do with people who are facing separation anxiety with their dogs that helps to keep the dog engaged and become more used to the idea of their human stepping away. Here’s the outline: Place your dog in a stay Walk away from your dog without making a big fuss. In the beginning, stay close to them. After a few moments have passed and your dog has not broken their stay, walk back to them and calmly give them a treat. Walk away again and repeat! Slowly increase your distance and duration over time to the point where you can step out of sight without your dog becoming anxious or breaking their stay. Now you might think this is just a place-stay exercise. To a degree it is, but the focus behind this is to show your dog that when they stay put and don’t make a fuss or begin to whine or stress out that is the behavior you are looking for and they’ll be rewarded. We want our dogs to become used to the sight and sound of us walking away from them, leaving them alone. This is just one exercise, and it may or may not work for your dog because as with all things dog training, there is no cookie-cutter approach! You may have to try different variations of the idea or something completely different to start to get results, but the goal behind it is the same. You might not see improvement in your dog’s behavior for some time. You also could have some really good days in a row, start to think things are getting better, and then out of nowhere your dog reverts into their typical freak-out self. That can be an incredibly disheartening moment, but take a breath and evaluate. When we are working on behavior improvements with our dog, your dog may experience something that’s called an “extinction burst.” This is where their behavior gets really bad, sometimes worse than it was before. When this happens, you don’t cave or give up! You have to stay consistent and committed to your process and work through it. There is a light at the end of the tunnel, and that light is your dog’s bad behavior going extinct. It is not an easy thing to deal with, especially when it’s based around separation anxiety. Be patient with yourself, be patient with your dog. Try to understand the scenario from the dog’s perspective. Start with baby steps, then slowly increase those over time. And if it’s just too much for you, get help from a professional dog trainer.
By Savannah Hamann June 28, 2024
Sure, foundation cues such as "sit and stay" are important. But are they everything?
By Savannah Hamann April 11, 2024
Three FUN activities you can do with your four-legged friend!
By Savannah Hamann March 6, 2024
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, these trails offer scenic views, fresh air, and a chance for your furry companion to stretch their legs. 🐾
By Savannah Hamann February 27, 2024
Congratulations! You are taking the first step in one of the most important responsibilities of having a dog.
By Savannah Hamann February 27, 2024
Lets face it, when you see those big round eyes looking up at you it's almost impossible to say no!
By Savannah Hamann February 27, 2024
Note: Please always consider adopting from your local shelter or rescue!
By Savannah Hamann February 27, 2024
The cuteness fades when your little puppy decides they’re the villain in your story…
By Savannah Hamann February 27, 2024
“I’ll run my dog for two miles and they’ll still bounce off the walls when we get home… They never stop!”
By Savannah Hamann February 27, 2024
In a world with so much information available at the drop of a hat, is it really worth working with a dog trainer?
More Posts
Share by: